Jump to content
NOTICE TO BOAY'ers: Major Update Coming ×
Bit Of A Yarn

Unnormalized Data Leads To Pointless Presentations?


Yankiwi

Recommended Posts

3 hours ago, Chief Stipe said:

So explain the reasons for the variance in the start of Q3 compare to YTD for Cambridge.

Unnormalized data used for pointless presentations has no variance applied.

image.png.77bbbe0a4ef6f2198c2cc7b1212b71ee.png

If that's what you want to do, have at it.

Then you can add your deviation to it.

image.png.88d3604602fa75c88306f4351a825f85.png

 

 

In my world, one dog injured is one dog injured. Those not injured are not injured.

In your world because so many dogs were not injured, even the ones that did get injured, didn't get injured.

 

My variables are Column "A" to Column "I" which are manually entered.

Formulas in Column "J" to "L" are constant.

 

Q3 Cambridge.

image.png.2a9129f039b35ac736bb553b79e911c7.png

 

(0+0+2)/442 = .0045 = Major injuries = 0.5%

image.png.bd1413e7526eb8fe4abbf4551fb093f7.png

 

(10+7)/442 = .0384 = Minor injuries = 3.8%

image.png.3f3ce388084bf9031d6e4ec195848b1b.png

 

Season to date Cambridge.

image.png.6f8bf424e0466c164e4dfc5003ef4802.png

 

(0+2+10)/2490 = .0048 = Major injuries = 0.5%

image.png.9548b572f3ba47434419843c31333c0d.png

 

(25+44)/2490 = .0277 = Minor injuries = 2.8%

image.png.1b3472b48dc2cbda514946776b89f7fa.png

 

Column L = J###/C### = Total Injuries

 

Think twice before taking your racing greyhound to Auckland. I hear Invercargill is nice this time of year.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Yankiwi said:

Unnormalized data used for pointless presentations has no variance applied.

image.png.77bbbe0a4ef6f2198c2cc7b1212b71ee.png

If that's what you want to do, have at it.

Then you can add your deviation to it.

image.png.88d3604602fa75c88306f4351a825f85.png

 

 

In my world, one dog injured is one dog injured. Those not injured are not injured.

In your world because so many dogs were not injured, even the ones that did get injured, didn't get injured.

 

My variables are Column "A" to Column "I" which are manually entered.

Formulas in Column "J" to "L" are constant.

 

Q3 Cambridge.

image.png.2a9129f039b35ac736bb553b79e911c7.png

 

(0+0+2)/442 = .0045 = Major injuries = 0.5%

image.png.bd1413e7526eb8fe4abbf4551fb093f7.png

 

(10+7)/442 = .0384 = Minor injuries = 3.8%

image.png.3f3ce388084bf9031d6e4ec195848b1b.png

 

Season to date Cambridge.

image.png.6f8bf424e0466c164e4dfc5003ef4802.png

 

(0+2+10)/2490 = .0048 = Major injuries = 0.5%

image.png.9548b572f3ba47434419843c31333c0d.png

 

(25+44)/2490 = .0277 = Minor injuries = 2.8%

image.png.1b3472b48dc2cbda514946776b89f7fa.png

 

Column L = J###/C### = Total Injuries

 

Think twice before taking your racing greyhound to Auckland. I hear Invercargill is nice this time of year.

So you can't explain the difference 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

18 hours ago, Chief Stipe said:

So explain the reasons for the variance in the start of Q3 compare to YTD for Cambridge.

I have answered your question. I do not apply a variance.

I've explained the variables.

Date - track - starters - 1/10 - 11/21 - 22/42 - 43/90 - death.

I have shown you the basic math equations to calculate the injury percentages.

If you're not happy with that, nothing I will ever say will make you happy.

It's what I'm doing & has proven effective (as it is in line with GRNZ's Q1 data they have released).

I've made Q2 data available as it was occurring, something everyone would have had to wait until mid/end of March to get from GRNZ.

I'm making Q3 data available as it is occurring, something everyone would have had to wait until mid/end of June to get from GRNZ.

If you don't like that & you want to minimize the impact the numbers of dogs that actually get hurt without improving welfare or safety, your target should be GRNZ's database administrator, not me. I'm not reporting to the Govt.

I am bringing attention (page hits) to your forum, something I thought you might actually appreciate. Without me, your forum would be on par with your old hang-outs greyhound forum.

You're welcome.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...
  • 3 months later...

2023/2024 Season Totals.

Overall KPI not achieved in any category (Total, Minor/Medium, or Major.

My takeaway. At least for major injuries, I believe the KPI is achievable if (and that's a big IF) GRNZ monitors individual track injury statistics in real time & doesn't wait around forever to made needed improvement to the track.

If they fixed Manukau & Addington when the shocking injury rates were first being detected, overall KPI achievement would have been a breeze. Those tracks would have been "out of service" for the same amount of time, but by delaying their repairs until a more convenient time, it really came back to bite them in the ass, in more ways than one.

image.thumb.png.189315ead3b6bf6b9f426ba1e38efdff.png

 

2022/2023 compared to 2023/2024 seasons.

Up in all categories.

  • Total injuries - 22/23 = 24.2 per thousand. 23/24 = 25.9 per thousand (+1.7 per thousand)
  • Minor/Med injuries - 22/23 = 17.9 per thousand. 23/24 = 19 per thousand (+1.1 per thousand)
  • Major1/2/Death - 22/23 = 6.33 per thousand. 23/24 = 6.84 per thousand (+.5 per thousand)
Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 minutes ago, Yankiwi said:

My takeaway. At least for major injuries, I believe the KPI is achievable if (and that's a big IF) GRNZ monitors individual track injury statistics in real time & doesn't wait around forever to made needed improvement to the track.

WTF does "measure in real time mean"?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Yankiwi said:

Don't you know how your website works?

image.png.bfa777f1a4b6cd8d798d493c25e6779c.png

So you are posting old data faking it as new.  With all the time you have on your hands I'd expect you'd be real time.

Posting end of quarter data before the end of quarter.  I guess that's future time not real time.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Point 1) You don't know how quoting a previous post works on your website.

When you quote a previous post (a couple weeks old in this case) it brings that already existing data into the new post.

 

Point 2) No racing on today (31 Jul) means 23/24 Q4 & Season are effectively completed.

image.png.60e77562072dcc79b9a15f1b9a621712.png

Grow up Chief.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

11 hours ago, Chief Stipe said:

I'd expect you'd be real time.

I did post real time data.

Has GRNZ posted completed 23/24 season data, no. I have.

Has GRNZ posted 23/24 Q4 data, no. I have.

FFS, GRNZ hasn't even made their 23/24 Q3 injury data public yet! Q3 ended 3 months ago.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Yankiwi said:

I did post real time data.

You don't even know what the term means.

1 hour ago, Yankiwi said:

Has GRNZ posted completed 23/24 season data, no. I have

But you don't have access to ALL the data.

1 hour ago, Yankiwi said:

FFS, GRNZ hasn't even made their 23/24 Q3 injury data public yet! Q3 ended 3 months ago.

I didn't realise they had a KPI to do so.  Perhaps unlike you they are collating their data from multiple sources and checking for errors.

Your data is often erroneous and your presentation of it more so.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Yankiwi said:

Point 1) You don't know how quoting a previous post works on your website.

Really @Yankiwi you're an expert on that as well?

1 hour ago, Yankiwi said:

When you quote a previous post (a couple weeks old in this case) it brings that already existing data into the new post.

Which means it is old data that you are republishing I.e. it isn't real time.

1 hour ago, Yankiwi said:

Grow up Chief.

The point was that you don't have access to ALL the data.  Hell you even made a point that a dog was found injured well AFTER the race.

I suggest you get a life or modify your obsession.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Overall injuries Major 1, Major 2 & Euth.

 

23/24 season (my data) .68% of all starters.

22/23 season (GRNZ) .63% of all starters.

21/22 season (GRNZ) .67% of all starters.

20/21 season (GRNZ) .69% of all starters.

GRNZ did not provide injury data publicly for previous seasons.

 

If GRNZ shut down Manukau in November 2023 for its refurb and transferred racing operations to Cambridge, instead of waiting until March 2024 to do it, their overall KPI for major injuries may have been achieved.

 

image.thumb.png.95d9896f2e88cc8c89bc066c0387ed53.png

 

 

On top of that, GRNZ constantly singled the need to refurb Addington, yet delayed & waited until they could most conveniently fit it into the schedule.

If they acted with haste, once the need had been identified, and actioned Manukau in November which was blatantly obvious, their KPI for major injuries would have been easily met.

The failure rests solely on decision GRNZ had made.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Yankiwi said:

If GRNZ shut down Manukau in November 2023 for its refurb and transferred racing operations to Cambridge, instead of waiting until March 2024 to do it, their overall KPI for major injuries may have been achieved.

There is no evidence that you have presented that supports that statement.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Chief Stipe said:

There is no evidence that you have presented that supports that statement.

In the interim, I have my data to support my claim.

Six months from now, when GRNZ finally releases their full season injury data, my statement will become officially substantiated.

You can countdown the 180 days if you'd like to Chief.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Yankiwi said:

In the interim, I have my data to support my claim.

Six months from now, when GRNZ finally releases their full season injury data, my statement will become officially substantiated.

You can countdown the 180 days if you'd like to Chief.

Quite frankly I have better things to do.  I disagree you have valid data.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...