Agree wrt Wellington. They have made some awful decisions, or been coerced into them, either way they have stuffed what was a fantastic carnival.
But I disagree with NM about carnivals, I think they work - provided that due attention is given to timing etc. And programming/dates are a huge issue in that respect. For starters, having three or more days at one venue, or close by, justifies the expense for both horses and connections to actually make the trip. Add that to a decent club [a few left ? ] making efforts to provide packages/discounts to visitors for accommodation, meals, and transport costs, and the whole thing becomes viable.
I'm referring to both sorts of 'carnivals' too, the top-end ones such as the Cup meetings at Wellington, Riccarton, Auckland as they USED to be, as well as the country holiday circuits.
I recall a particular comment from a former regular poster about Gisborne/ Wairoa being 'too costly' 'a waste of time' 'get rid of them'. I presume he was referring to floating costs, I hope he is pleased to now transport his horse to a borefest of a nothing meeting at Hastings.