Not possible to rate great horses from different eras and regimes...IMO...suffice to say that Winx would NEVER have been treated like Show Gate was.
La Mer was racing around the same time, on occasion they were compared as well, unfairly. La Mer also was treated like a princess, and would never have been subjected to the handling that Show Gate experienced.
Dunedin Gold Cup [ mile and a half ] then, the next day, the Timaru Cup [ one mile ]. Her incredible feats at NZ Cup meeting on that short prep, as outlined above.
We have all seen horses, unused to stable life, melt down when removed from their familiar paddocks. The only time Show Gate went to Aus, she just didn't cope at all. It wasn't lack of class that felled her, it was just an environment that she was completely unsuited to, and given no chance to adapt.
We had a useful two year old, way back, called Zebak. Won the Champagne stakes, and then lined up and won the 1400m two year old race later in the meeting.
His owners were sitting at the stables on the Sunday after, having a half-G and reminiscing, as was the habit, when a truck pulled in over in the visitors' area. It had come from Lyttelton and was carrying Show Gate, among others.
One of the guys went over and stuck his head around the corner, came back and said, you wouldn't believe it, that mare is standing in the pissing rain and cold wind, with a cotton sheet on, shivering, and trying to pick at some chaff in a feedbin on the ground before the wind blew it away. It took a bit of persuasion to stop him taking a warmer rug over to put on her.
Mouse [McCann] was at Trentham and witnessed Show Gate taken into the birdcage, covered in shit and dirt. Gordy was told to take her away and tidy her up. He put the saddle on the weigh-in stalls, took her away and hosed her all over, brought her back in and saddled her again. Gospel. Think she won the Trentham Stakes.