Enthusiast,you make some very valid points.What is the fairest way to decide which dog(s) advance into The Cup Final,especially if a rerun on the day is deemed not possible.If the non race is at least half completed,I would give most weight as to how the race was unfolding,and where dogs were positioned at time of lure being caught.Now,I never saw video of this race in question,so have no idea where Dyna Dave was sitting.However,I have spoken to Dave Fahey (who to my mind is a great judge and doesn't make false boasts),that his Opawa Dog was going on to win this heat before the lure failure.I hate the old system of drawing out of hat,totally unfair.Over 15 years ago,my dog was going to run top two and qualify for Auckland Cup,when lure stopped in home straight.Names drawn out of hat,7th and 8th favourites qualified.Needless to say they were the rank outsiders and ran accordingly.It still rankles that TAB wouldn't refund my Futures Fixed Odds Bets following a non race,where all tote bets got refunds!